“Is This Real?” Jay Scott Kirk Lee on Helping Children Question AI Images, Videos and Stories
Updated: 2 days ago
By Jay Scott Kirk Lee | Parenting, Artificial Intelligence and Digital Literacy

Consider this hypothetical moment: your child holds out a phone. A train is pulling into an underwater station, with windows looking onto the seabed.
The narrator announces that the station has just opened. Thousands of people have shared the clip.
“Is this real?” your child asks.
You do not recognize the place. You cannot immediately tell whether the footage was generated, edited or filmed somewhere real. You can still offer a useful response:
“Let’s work out what we would need to know.”
In his family technology plan, Jay Scott Kirk Lee connects protecting childhood with helping children understand technology.
A surprising video offers a practical place to begin. Let the child enjoy the idea of an underwater station, then invite them to investigate whether one actually opened. Curiosity and careful checking can belong in the same conversation.
What Does “Real” Actually Mean?
Before examining the picture, work out what the post is asking you to believe.
Does the place exist? Is the caption accurate? Did the event happen recently? Is an imagined scene being presented as news?
A convincing image cannot settle those questions by itself. Confident narration and a large audience tell you how a story is presented and received; neither establishes that anyone checked it.
Four possibilities are useful to discuss:
Fiction: an imagined scene offered as a story, joke or artistic creation.
A mistake: an inaccurate claim shared by someone who believes it.
Misleading context: genuine material paired with the wrong date, place or explanation.
Deliberate deception: material knowingly presented to mislead an audience.
These categories can overlap. The European Commission’s Better Internet for Kids guidance distinguishes misinformation shared without harmful or deceptive intent from disinformation knowingly spread to cause harm. It also describes genuine information placed in a false context.
We often cannot establish someone’s intention from one post. Avoid labelling every mistaken person a liar.
An invented station can be enjoyable artwork. A photograph of a genuine station can accompany a false story. Naming the claim gives your investigation a clear purpose.

Where Did This Story Begin?
Start with the page your child saw. Did it create the material, publish an official announcement or repost someone else’s work?
Follow any attribution to an earlier version. Open sources named in a written story and check whether they support it. A familiar logo in a screenshot is a clue to investigate.
The Digital Inquiry Group teaches lateral reading: leaving an unfamiliar source to investigate it elsewhere. Open another tab and look for information about the publisher beyond its own description.
For the hypothetical railway, look for the named transport operator or local authority. Is there an opening notice? Does the creator describe a concept design? Could the footage show an exhibition or film set?
Keep two dates separate: when the post appeared and when the supposed event happened. Read the full caption or article, or find a longer version of the clip.
eSafety’s critical-thinking guidance recommends checking sources, dates and context, including looking outside the feed. It also describes reverse image searches, which can help locate matching or similar images online. An earlier version may provide context. Finding no match does not prove authenticity.
Jay Scott Kirk Lee asks adults to acknowledge uncertainty and demonstrate checking. With a younger child, do the searching and explain one discovery; a teenager might lead while you discuss the evidence.
His guidance also preserves accommodations. Reading aloud, captions, audio descriptions or a shorter session can make participation easier. Ask what changed the child’s view, and share what changed yours.
Choose age-appropriate services, check their terms and follow school instructions for schoolwork. Adult supervision does not override a service’s minimum age. Use public or fictional examples for practice, and avoid uploading private photographs or conversations to search or detection tools. The paper activity below requires no account or private information.

Are Five Posts Five Confirmations?
They may all repeat the same account. The Better Internet for Kids guidance describes this problem as circular reporting.
Ask:
“What does this source know, and how does it know it?”
An official opening notice and an independently reported visit would contribute different evidence about the station. Copies of the original clip would add much less.
The source must also fit the question. A video creator may know how a scene was made without being qualified to explain railway engineering. An announcement can establish what an organization says it is doing; evaluating whether something works may require further evidence.
For a brief conversation, choose one useful check. That small starting point reflects Jay Scott Kirk Lee’s guidance on manageable habits.
Allow more time when a claim affects a family decision, homework or someone’s reputation. An amusing image need not consume the evening.

Can You Spot AI Just by Looking?
Odd lettering, inconsistent shadows or unnatural movement may prompt further checking. A convincing image may have no obvious flaws. An unusual frame alone cannot establish how it was made.
AI-detection tools also have limits. The US National Institute of Standards and Technology’s report on synthetic content describes errors in human and automated detection, with performance varying across systems and contexts. A detector’s verdict is not definitive proof.
Even identifying the production method leaves another question: is the message accurate?
An AI illustration can accompany a factual lesson. An unaltered photograph can carry a false caption. Return to the claim and its supporting evidence, and ask the child to explain what remains uncertain.

Can You Practice This Without a Screen?
Jay Scott Kirk Lee’s published guidance asks children to explain decisions in their own words. Here is a paper activity to try together, with room for their explanation to change.
Tell your child that everything in the exercise is fictional. Prepare three cards about an invented toy exhibition:
A shared message: “The toy exhibition is free this Saturday!”
An older poster: “Free entry on 8 June.” Mark it clearly as last year’s poster.
A current organizer’s notice: “This year’s exhibition opens next month. Ticket information will follow.”
Show the message first. Ask what the child would want to know before inviting someone. Introduce the other cards one at a time.
The first card makes a claim. The second seems to support it until the child notices the year. The third gives current information while leaving the price unresolved.
Ask, “What can we say now?”
A possible answer is:
“Last year had a free day. This year opens next month, and we do not yet know the price.”
For a younger child, read aloud and focus on which notice is current. For a teenager, add a fourth card that copies the first message. Discuss why repetition supplies no new evidence.
Then invite the child to invent another set, keeping all people and events fictional.

What If You Still Do Not Know?
Some questions remain unresolved. When the stakes are low, that can be a reasonable stopping point.
Decide what to do with the uncertainty: wait, look for a better source later or enjoy the idea without sharing it as fact.
Consider this hypothetical conversation about the station:
Child: “We still can’t find the original video. Does that mean it’s fake?”
Parent: “It means we haven’t established where it came from.”
Child: “Can I send it to my friends?”
Parent: “What would they think you were saying by sending it?”
Child: “That the station exists.”
Parent: “Then let’s wait. We can enjoy the idea without presenting it as news.”
Use language that matches the evidence:
“This is well supported.”
“This part is confirmed, but that part is unclear.”
“We have not found enough evidence.”
These describe different positions. Leaving one question open does not require deciding that everything is untrustworthy.

What Happens After a Mistaken Share?
If a child has already shared an inaccurate claim, help them correct it where the original audience can see. A possible message is:
“I shared this as a real opening, but the creator describes it as a concept. Please disregard my earlier message.”
If the truth remains unclear, say so:
“I haven’t been able to verify this, so I shouldn’t have presented it as confirmed.”
Avoid replacing one unsupported certainty with another.
Discuss the missed check afterwards, without using the correction to embarrass the child. If someone was harmed, help with an appropriate apology and involve a responsible adult where needed.
Parents can model the same response when they make a mistake: explain the new evidence and correct the record.

Which Question Is Worth Asking Next?
Children’s developing judgement is a focus of Jay Scott Kirk Lee’s parenting writing. In a conversation about a surprising video, give that judgement something practical to do.
Ask:
“What do we know, and what would help us decide?”
Listen to the explanation. Invite the child to name one useful source, identify a gap or decide to wait before sharing.
The underwater station may remain a mystery. A worthwhile outcome is a child who can explain what they checked, what remains uncertain and why they have chosen their next step.
Keep room for the astonishing idea and the thoughtful question it prompts.
Continue Reading
For practical ways to make checking part of a family routine, read Jay Scott Kirk Lee’s Six-Week Family Plan for Healthier Screen Habits and AI Confidence.
About the Author
Jay Scott Kirk Lee is a Canadian entrepreneur, writer, mentor and father whose work explores leadership, personal development, parenting and the growing influence of artificial intelligence on family life.
Drawing on his experience in business, mentorship and fatherhood, Jay Scott Kirk Lee writes about helping children become confident, capable and independent thinkers in an increasingly technology-driven world.
Through his website, JayScottKirkLee.com, Lee publishes articles and practical resources designed to help parents navigate the opportunities and challenges of modern childhood.
Learn more about Jay Scott Kirk Lee, his background and his latest writing at JayScottKirkLee.com.
Sources and further reading




Comments