top of page

Jay Scott Kirk Lee’s Guide to Teaching Children to Question AI Answers Without Becoming Suspicious of Everything

Jay Scott Kirk Lee
2 days ago
6 min read

By Jay Scott Kirk Lee

A father and child compare an AI chat answer with a museum webpage on a laptop in a bright learning space.

Imagine this hypothetical exchange at the kitchen table. A child has brought an answer from a permitted AI activity: “An octopus has eight arms and two hearts.”

Together, you check a Natural History Museum article about octopuses. Eight arms is correct. The number of hearts should be three.

Then comes the harder question: “If it can get that wrong, how do we know when to believe it?”

That deserves more than a warning about unreliable technology. It is an opportunity to help a child decide what deserves confidence, what needs another look and what can remain unanswered for now.

Jay Scott Kirk Lee’s published parenting guidance keeps children actively involved in thinking, choosing and explaining decisions. Applied to AI answers, that principle gives parents a practical starting point: help children find reasons for the conclusions they reach.

Sometimes those reasons will support an answer. Sometimes they will change it. Both are useful outcomes.

What does an AI mistake actually tell us?

A fluent answer can still contain an error. The US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) describes confidently presented false information in its Generative Artificial Intelligence Profile. It also explains that generative systems can produce accurate information.

That leaves families with a specific question: which parts of this answer have enough support for the way we want to use them?

In the octopus example, the heart count needs correcting. The arm count has independent support. Neither finding settles the accuracy of a longer answer about an octopus’s diet, behaviour or habitat.

Help your child keep the conclusion proportionate: “We checked these two details. We can keep one and correct the other.”

If the incorrect detail affects a drawing or school task, update that work too. There is no need to defend the mistake or discard information you have good grounds to accept.

A child compares an AI response with a reference webpage and edits one detail on a laptop while their father watches.

First, ask what kind of answer you are looking at

An AI response may combine facts, ideas and advice in the same paragraph. Each calls for a different kind of judgement.

A factual claim needs evidence. “An octopus has three hearts” is a statement about the world. A relevant, dependable reference can help establish whether it is correct.

A suggestion needs a purpose. A proposed name for a homemade game can be judged by whether the players like it and whether it suits what they are making. There may be several good choices.

Advice needs context. A recommendation about which activity a child should choose may depend on their interests, available time and other people’s needs. Check any factual assumptions, then discuss the decision with the people involved.

Ask your child what they are trying to learn or do before deciding how to assess the response.

For example, an answer suggesting a museum visit might contain an appealing idea and an incorrect opening time. The family can keep the idea while checking the hours on the museum’s own current visitor page.

A father and child discuss different parts of an AI response on a tablet at a café table.

Look for evidence that answers the actual question

A link at the end of an AI answer is a starting point for checking. Open it. Does the page exist? Who produced it? Does it support the particular claim you are relying on?

NIST notes that generated citations and explanations can themselves be fabricated. A source can also be real without establishing the conclusion attached to it.

Match the source to the question. A museum’s natural-history resource may help with an animal fact. An organiser’s current notice is a suitable place to check its event arrangements. A teacher can clarify what a particular assignment requires.

For an unfamiliar website, look beyond its own description of itself. The Digital Inquiry Group’s teaching materials on lateral reading explain checking other sources to learn about the site supplying information.

Younger children can help identify the sentence that answers their question while an adult handles the searching. Older children might explain why a source is relevant and whether its information is current enough.

Asking the same chatbot “Are you sure?” can continue the conversation, but its reply is not an independent check. Evaluate any new evidence it offers in the same way.

A child opens an independent reference page beside an AI chat at a library computer station while their father looks on.

Practice recognising when an answer is useful

Try this optional activity without opening an AI tool. Invent a simple tabletop game and agree that each player starts with four counters. Leave the game’s name and starting order undecided.

Explain that the following are pretend chatbot responses written for the exercise:

Ask: “Which suggestions would you keep, and why?”

All three might be usable. The reasons differ: one matches an established fact about the game, one appeals to the players and one reflects a decision they have discussed.

Make space for a child to disagree with your preferred name or starting rule. Their explanation is part of the activity. They can show their thinking through speech, drawing, pointing or another familiar communication method.

Finish by playing. The discussion has done its job when the family has enough clarity to continue.

A father and child discuss an offline paper game with four wooden counters each and a closed tablet set aside.

How much checking does this decision need?

Checking should fit the consequences of being wrong.

Choosing a silly game name is easy to revisit. Relying on an incorrect deadline or acting on safety advice is different. Help children notice what could happen if an answer is mistaken and who should help with the decision.

For an ordinary factual question, an appropriate reference that directly addresses the point may be enough to proceed. A genuine contradiction, an unclear source or a consequential decision calls for more help. Counting matching webpages is no substitute for examining where their information comes from.

Children should not carry responsibility for evaluating consequential health, safety or financial advice alone. Involve an adult and seek an appropriate professional or authoritative resource where needed.

It is also reasonable to leave a non-urgent question open. “We have not found enough evidence yet” is a clear account of what you know. You can ask a librarian or teacher later, or decide the question does not need resolving today.

A father and child compare an AI outing suggestion with museum visitor information on a laptop.

Let children see you accept evidence, too

Jay Scott Kirk Lee asks adults to acknowledge uncertainty and demonstrate checking in his published family plan. Parents can make the whole process visible, including the moment they have enough reason to accept an answer.

Here is an illustrative conversation, continuing the hypothetical octopus example:

Child: “But what if the museum is wrong too?”

Parent: “Any source can need correcting. This is a museum resource explaining animal biology, and it directly answers our question about the hearts. That gives us a good reason to use it here.”

Child: “So we can write three?”

Parent: “Yes. We can explain where we checked it. If good evidence changes our understanding later, we can update it.”

The parent offers a reason for trust and leaves room for revision. There is no requirement to prove that every possible mistake has been ruled out.

Shared exploration also appears in UNICEF’s interview on parenting in the AI age, which encourages adults and children to approach unfamiliar technology as learners together.

Keep the conversation welcoming. Thank a child for noticing a discrepancy, including one you overlooked. Invite them to show what they understand and where they need help. Reading support, translation, assistive technology and other accommodations can remain available throughout.

A child explains a checked reference page on a tablet while their father listens beside them.

Keep the routine small enough to use

Choose an occasional question that matters to your child. Talk about the answer, check what matters and agree on what to do next. Every interaction does not need to become an investigation.

Before any live AI activity, check the service’s age requirements, terms, privacy arrangements and relevant school rules. Adult supervision does not override age restrictions. Keep identifying details and private schoolwork out of prompts; fictional examples work for these discussions.

A paper exercise, a book or a conversation with a teacher may suit the task better. Children do not need a chatbot account to practise these decisions.

Jay Scott Kirk Lee’s emphasis on manageable family practices offers a sensible place to finish. Leave time for the curiosity that started the question: draw the octopus, play the game or explore something new.

Useful questioning reaches a decision. Sometimes that decision is to correct an answer, sometimes to wait, and sometimes to trust the evidence and move on.

The question to carry forward is simple: “What makes this answer good enough for what we need to do?”

A father and child finish a brief AI answer check on a laptop beside an open garden door.

Continue reading

For more ideas on everyday family routines, read the six-week family plan for healthier screen habits and AI confidence.

About the author

Jay Scott Kirk Lee is a Canadian entrepreneur, writer, mentor and father whose work explores leadership, personal development, parenting and the growing influence of artificial intelligence on family life.


Drawing on his experience in business, mentorship and fatherhood, Jay Scott Kirk Lee writes about helping children become confident, capable and independent thinkers in an increasingly technology-driven world.


Through his website, JayScottKirkLee.com, Lee publishes articles and practical resources designed to help parents navigate the opportunities and challenges of modern childhood.


Learn more about Jay Scott Kirk Lee, his background and his latest writing at JayScottKirkLee.com.

Sources

Comments


bottom of page